Watchdog: How can O.C. residents be using less water, but paying more?

It’s a modest Irvine tract house, ensconced in a modest quantity of greenery. Nona Demetre considers her water use modest as well – however her monthly bill shot up 34 percent over the path of a single year nonetheless.

“As a retiree, I have actually been fairly conscious regarding conserving water in order to sustain my bill low,” Demetre protested to the Irvine Ranch Water District, detailing exactly how her monthly bill grew to $48. “As rates have actually been increasing every year, it appears to be an effort in futility.”

Like lots of drought-plagued Californians, Demetre is vexed by paying ever much more while using ever less. Irvine Ranch’s rates flower again on July 1. So even after cutting outdoor watering by a third, Demetre’s bill remains the same.

It’s a conundrum statewide: Officials reason that individuals conserve water. individuals respond, and water use goes down. however much less water sold means much less cash flowing in to public coffers, so prices rise to make up for lost revenue.

Folks feel that they’re being punished for conserving. however just what else can easily the water agencies do to cover fixed costs, which don’t fluctuate Enjoy the rain?

“Sure, ‘use much less water, pay much more for it,’ is a sturdy pill to swallow,” said Yorba Linda Water District President Ric Collett in a letter explaining why straightforward service charges in the hot, hilly horse country are slated to jump from $16.77 to $41.77 this fall. “However, in reality, it’s ‘use much less water, pay much more to guarantee it is there as quickly as you necessity it.’”

Southern California cities and water districts are selling much less water now compared to they did spine in 2003, however are bringing in more cash nonetheless, a Register analysis found. Rising rates are an integral section of that equation, and Irvine Ranch and Yorba Linda are not alone: The cost of water has actually doubled and rates at most agencies have actually risen in recent years, and is expected to rise even more.

• Among retail water agencies in Orange County, revenue flower an standard of 54 percent over 11 years, according to data from the state controller’s office.

• Among O.C. cities that furnish water service, revenue flower 78 percent over 12 years.

• And among water managers, importers and wholesalers – agencies that pump it from the ground or import it from far away, after that sell it to the agencies that ultimately sell it to you – revenue flower 46 percent over 12 years.


“Overall, costs are fixed and there’s a great deal of capital in the ground,” said Gary Breaux, chief financial officer for the giant, 87-year-old Metropolitan Water District of Southern California, which falls in to that last category.

“You’re using much less however your bill could continue to be the same, and individuals are like, ‘It must go down.’ I’ve had those discussions lots of times, however it comes down to this: Water is vital to day-to-day living. The costs are to grab it to the tap, safe to drink.”

MWD is the granddaddy of them all, importing water so 19 million individuals can easily live in this desert we call home. In 2003, it sold 2.3 million acre-feet of water, and had $1.1 billion in total revenue.

In 2013, despite much more compared to a million brand-new individuals in SoCal, MWD’s water sales were down considerably – by 17 percent, to 1.9 million acre-feet. however revenue had grown much more compared to 46 percent, to $1.6 billion.

That can easily happen since MWD has actually much more compared to doubled the rate of its water, from $408 an acre-foot in 2003 to $890 in 2014. Rates went up 1.5 percent on Jan. 1, and will certainly go up yet another 1.5 percent in 2016. That will certainly trickle down to lots of local cities and water districts.

Groundwater – mostly pumped by the Orange County Water District – is far cheaper. however it, too, has actually much more compared to doubled in cost, from $127 per acre-foot in 2003 to $276 in 2014.

That makes People cranky.

“Rates are constantly going up and they have actually a half-billion dollars in their reserves,” said activist and critic John Jaeger of Irvine Ranch. “It’s outrageous.”

The economics behind water pricing are a story of economic scarcity in action, touching every Californian that washes dishes or takes a bath. They’re rooted in a fundamental disconnect: Seventy percent of California’s precipitation falls north of Sacramento, while 75 percent of the reason for water is south of Sacramento, according to the Water Education Foundation.


One official wryly noted that water agencies are spending millions of dollars to tell individuals not to buy their product.

“The hard truth is that the drought has actually a rate tag,” said Cindie Ryan, spokeswoman for the city of Brea, which imports all its water.

“It will certainly hit the pocketbook of everyone in California and there is no avoiding it. however employing good conservation habits now will certainly advice mitigate future costs to the very best extent possible. … The rate tag to California, and by extension, cities and people would certainly be even greater absent strict conservation measures.”

And don’t count on El Niño to save you. Big rains frequently translate in to even much less water used, making budget holes even bigger.

Higher revenue reflects the pass-through of greater costs to consumers, as well as interest income and growing property tax revenue for the agencies that grab them (not all of do), officials said.

Costs have actually been going up as well. In addition to the rise in the rate of water, it costs much more to deliver it and to keep and increase the delivery systems. Especially among cities, there has actually been a burst of catch-up to refresh saggy old infrastructure that was neglected as quickly as times were tight, to prevent UCLA-type flooding.

The revenue enhances reflect additional millions for capital improvement projects, officials said.

“Aside from the truth that public utilities have actually not communicated the true value of water effectively, there is likewise a lack of public discovering concerning just what it requires to offer safe, reliable drinking water to customers,” said Alma Flores, spokeswoman for the city of Santa Ana.

“For utilities along with debt obligations, fixed costs make up anywhere from 75 to 90 percent of total costs. This percentage is lower for those utilities along with no debt burden. Consequently, even if no water is sold, utilities still have actually substantial costs that need to be covered.”

To that end, exactly how you pay for water is in the midst of change.

There are two sections to your water bill: the service charge, which is meant to cover fixed operating costs; and the commodity charge, which is supposed to cover the cost of water itself.

Historically, lots of agencies depended heavily on the commodity charge to make ends meet. along with water consumption down, that’s changing.

‘individuals CUSSing AT ME’

The starkest illustration could be in Yorba Linda, where the fixed service charge is slated to rise to $41.77 from the present $16.77. Unlike most others water districts, Yorba Linda has actually kept its fiscal reserves low, so it doesn’t have actually much of a money cushion. The governor’s 36 percent conservation mandate for the district is translating in to a sudden 36 percent shed in revenue – regarding $10 million.

The district has to dramatically restructure its rates or face insolvency.

“This isn’t something we Enjoy to do and it’s not something we wish to do,” said spokesman Damon Micalizzi. “Our rates have actually been the lowest in the land forever, and we have actually big green lots that individuals watered along with abandon.

“The $700 bills subsidized those that didn’t pay as much, however that has actually got to change. I’ve had individuals cussing at me, however after we explain, they wish to go out for coffee. They could not Enjoy it, however they understand.”

The standard water bill in Yorba Linda is regarding $85 now. After a 36 percent reduction in water use and the price hike, it will certainly still be regarding $85, Micalizzi said.

The Santa Margarita Water District, one of the county’s largest, recently examined its price structure and found that fixed charges only covered regarding 40 percent of fixed costs.

Even prior to the drought, that presented challenges, said spokesman Jonathan Volzke: Water sales, and therefore revenue, peaked in the summer then trailed off in the winter.

In March, the district hiked fixed charges from $6.41 to $8.72 for most single-family homes, while dropping the water charge regarding twenty cents a unit. Four much more annual enhances are on the way, and the district is embracing “water budgets,” which set usage targets based on property, estate and family size.

The governor’s mandatory reductions are expected to cut Santa Margarita’s revenue by $6.8 million this year, Volzke said. To absorb that, the district is delaying equipment purchases and reducing exactly how much is socked in to reserves.


The East Orange County Water District, which acts as the two wholesaler and retailer, is exceeding its 36 percent reduction target thanks to July’s rains, and anticipates revenue losses of some $400,000, General Manager Lisa Ohlund said. It’s doing a cost-of-service analysis, and anticipates a “drought surcharge.”

“If we have actually a wet winter, that will certainly further exacerbate the revenue loss, and the drought surcharge will certainly probably continue to be in place longer – which will certainly be much more upsetting to our customers,” Ohlund said.

“The vast majority are quite discovering of the situation. I’ve been heartened by several of our customers who, while attending one of our drought outreach workshops, will certainly come up to us afterwards and pat our arms and tell us that points will certainly grab better.”

Contact the writer:

Leave a Reply